Elise_Elleneth The only problem in implementing a program for this would be that they just need to get some real words or sentences that don't have anything to do with the LN and spam that instead. I agree though. I really dislike those reviews. It use to be a LOT better on QI/WN and didn't have reviews like that. For about the first 2 years of the site most reviews actually had something to say. There were still some who would only say " Great Novel Great Novel". It wasn't as bad as it is now though.

These types of reviews really do make it hard to find legitimate reviews to read and see if you want to read the LN. They also flood out people how leave reviews about what they have read and wondering about if such and such thing changes later on in the story.

    And some of us can't be bothered to even delete the spam emoji reviews 😂. It depends on the author, but it's unusual for a author who has a novel that has so many ratings to spend so much time and effort to go through and delete bad reviews 🤔 because they'd have to go through a LOT.

    SorcererCat I am an author myself and I get a lot of 1 star review when the one making it doesn't even read my book that's what I delete 😆 I got a lot of low review too but I let it stay since it's from true reader even though they use mean words and insulting me so I think it depends on the author theirselves

      8 days later

      xeacarons I fully agree with you. But they did this to get people to put reviews up on new LNs that have little to no reviews. Maybe if they only gave exp once per LN or had an exp cap on this function it might help out.

          If authors remove 1 star reviews with 0 chapters read, it should automatically remove a 5 star review with 0 chapters read along with it. Otherwise, it doesnt matter what excuse authors give for removing 1 star reviews, if you're removing one because they didnt read your story, and not the 5 star ones for the same reason, you're doing precisely what the title says.

            sekmet022 Um, some authors remove 1 stars with 0 chapters read because of the emoji spam and XP spam? There's also some copy and pace reviews that users post on every single novel, indicating they didn't read it.

                sekmet022 I do agree with you. The only issue is that it seems that the phone app lets people read the LN and when leaving comments shows 0 for chapters read. At least that is what some people, on WN, have said. And others read the LN and don't login so it shows 0 chapters for them too. I don't know how these people are able to never get their read chapters updated, but it does seem that some of them fall into this situation.

                    XOMatsumaeohana And authors dont have 5 star reviews with the same thing? C'mon man.. lets not piss on people and tell them its raining, we both know that for every 1 star review that gets removed, theres a 5 star thats just as worthless. The only reason authors dont remove those 5 star reviews with tons of emojis or "expexpexpexp" is because it makes their novel's rating look better. Justify it all you want, i frankly find the double standards fairly amusing, but it pretty much means any author that practices this has 0 credibility/integrity, both as a human being and as an author.

                    SorcererCat In the end, its not really about the 0 chapters read, since anyone can click "Read" on the novel, then scroll down a couple of chapters so that it shows something other than 0 chapters read when they review. The main problem is the content of the reviews, a 1 star "This book sucks." should share about the same credibility as a 5 star "This book is great". Yet we both know only one of these will be getting removed. Reviews are not actually being used for reviewing, they're treated instead as a comment section to spam in without properly judging the contents of the novel.

                          sekmet022 I agree with you. Personally I wish they would get rid of both. I want to know why it was GREAT or why it was CRAP. All these spam reviews that say nothing or give no reasons are just a bunch of garbage and a waste of space.

                            Sighgray I'm ok with self reviews, WHAT I DONT GET THOUGH, is we are allowed to review more than once on same novel

                            Also even if we cant renove our own reviews dude, please note that a lot of people do review swaps, which is the TRUE FAKE RATINGS. At least with your own review, you are saying off your thought, and starting off your novel

                              6 days later

                              All these people that are saying that the author/translator should have this deleting power because of 1 star spam emoji reviews can go suck balls. I don't see them (author /translator ) delete 5 star emoji spam reviews, why should they be allowed to delete 1 star reviews. People should just be able to down vote a review and emoji's shouldn't be considered as letters in reviews.

                                Qwertg I agree with everything except down voting. The reason I say this is because then authors will just have 5-10 fake accounts and down vote ALL reviews they don't like. The rest is good though.

                                    I think sometimes it has to do with the quality of reviews some critics make. It's not an author's fault if some critics give blind praise to crappy works just to get a good one in return. I have nothing about review swaps but sometimes it can be a culprit to the artificial boosting trend.

                                    I thought CK said that translators couldn't delete their reviews?

                                    Scrolls up. Yep, he did.

                                      SorcererCat Well this platform is from China and it pretty much works in the way it works in that country, so if you've been in this business for a long time enough (like me :D), you wouldn't be surprised because that's the way they are overthere and nobody (both readers and writers) ever complains about it like you guys do about many things (not just reviews, you know, many other unreasonable stuff), so they just take it for granted and think it will surely work in intermational markets too ∠( ᐛ 」∠)＿Back there when I tried to complain they were just like "shut the fxxk up and follow the rules"∠( ᐛ 」∠)＿

                                      If you presume those people are qualified as writers with dignities then you couldn't be more wrong. Like I said, they are pimps who treat their novels like street girls and force them into whatever their tasteless customers like. They don't give a damn about the artistic value of literature. Even if WN updates the platform and shut down writers' ability of deleting 1-star review, they will probably just find their fanatic brainless fans in China and call on them to flood this place to add those 5-star spams and pour 1-stars onto whatever novels that are viewed to be "rivals".∠( ᐛ 」∠)＿They are businessmen, not authors, and the vulgar, villain type of businessmen, too.

                                      Addition: This is only a comment on those authors who delete bad reviews indiscriminately while their works are...objectively speaking, sxxt.∠( ᐛ 」∠)＿

                                        It would be easy to cut down spam reviews. Only allow one REVIEW OF EACH BOOK PER ACCOUNT and allow editing of reviews. And only allow reviewing if you are at least for example lvl2. Problem solved i think

                                        15 days later

                                        I wish this wasn't a problem. It's hard to trust a review section when the person with the most skin in the game can get rid of criticism with a couple of clicks. The review section is meant to be for the readers not the author. I know a lot of writers aren't like this and I've never seen the profiles translating novels get into trouble for it, but come on. In what world does it make sense for the author to have the power to look at their reviews and say "nope" to a bad one.

                                        Web Novel Novel Ask