- Edited
Rothfuss I just read like 500+ novels, so my expectations r just high. What I said was pure honesty, don't take it to heart that much though, every1 sucks at first, plus your story was mostly just grammercal stuff, as for the story plot, it might be good, it just doesn't fit my tastes though which is y I put 4 to be non biased, if u keep writing you'll improve, my first novel was god awful in everything, I never published it though, for my second I wrote with nk insperation and just a prize, other than grammer, everything else was pretty awful from a reader's perspective. You can usually judge your books qualities by these ratios (opion but what I can guess with my experience)
1-150:1 collection Amazing
151-250:1 collection Good
251-350:1 collection Above Average
351-450:1 collection Below Average
451+:1 collection Bad or horrible
This doesnt mean story itself is bad even if its 550:1, as most people get hooked at the start, and for me I just wasn't hooked as I read too many books, but thats also y I wrote a lot, I get reviews matter though so if u really want me to I'll edit it in future, but not listing things out, takes too much time
I don't really understand what u mean, but I hope this answers it