If you could review mine that would be splendid.
Novel Assessments & Reviews: Empowering Writers & Helping Readers
- Edited
Book_Keeper Thank you for the assessment and cant wait to read the review portion when available.
Also hopeful that plot will get better as I get more chapters out as well x3
Jamison_C
Thanks! You know, I was starting to feel something was off too. I noticed this due to your CL/RL and TQ/PD/CF suggestions. Some have great stories, the trio factors, but then get slightly deflated due to the duo. It's also the same vice versa. So in that sense, two stories were 'equally' good, but that one point of difference was due to the duo.
Hmm... I wonder if I should make subpages to address this issue....
StenDuring
Ah, no wonder! Haha, learning new things every day~
toomb Shotgun9494 Darkjokes
Got it, queued~
MuddyEarth
Nice suggestion! Will do~
Kyazi
You're welcome. And yes, PD is rather conservative for those with less chapters. With those around 100 chapters, it's typically a matter of whether PD will be 2 or 3 unless progress is very drawn out/slow.
- Edited
For reviews, I'm only going to do reviews when a novel hits 20 chapters/20,000+ words. I'm starting to find that it's trickier to properly judge PD and CF when the beginning is usually setup without seeing how initial events play out into another.
Darkjokes
Hey, I just realized now that the novel given is a fan-fiction. Unfortunately, I don't do fan-fictions.
As a refresher, I don't assess/review the following types:
- short stories
- one shots
- fan fictions
- featured stories
- contracted stories
- published stories
- non-English stories
For featured and contracted stories, I'm not always able to tell, so I'm trusting that the given stories aren't.
A quick answer to why I don't for all 7 types listed above is 1) It's already "successful" in some way. 2) It's not full length or completely "original." 3) I'm only confident in English, lol.
[EDIT: Just tried the "list" formatting, and it doesn't work, hah. ]
Book_Keeper
Shameless passerby here.
https://www.webnovel.com/book/12734433505930905/Immoral-System
Please be warned though, my novel uses language not for readers 17 and below. Peace sign
FallenBlue
Done. https://virtualbookshelf.home.blog/2019/02/05/webnovel-assessments-13/
Let me know if you want a review; although, the review for your story would be similar to ihateyounot's but less dark.
Book_Keeper Thanks, and I don't mind. I do want a review. XD
And sorry for the trouble.
- Edited
I submit my humble plebian self to your thorough scrutiny, oh great Book Keeper.
https://m.webnovel.com/book/12812950405462405
Please point out this humble one's most glaring flaws, so that I may endeavor myself to improve upon them. This humble one gives you his most heartfelt thanks.
UnliMegane
:laughing: I'm guessing you would like a review besides an assessment, so this lowly Book Keeper shall queue you.
Welp, let's see how bad is my fic LUL
https://www.webnovel.com/book/11086315406252105/Classmancers---A-MOBA-Esport-Story
Would be happy to get a review even if it's going to be a low score.
Well... I'm kind of a masochist, so...you can hit me as hard as you can, I really, really need some criticism so that I can grow as an author.
https://m.webnovel.com/book/12122078406956805
Review as harsh as you can do.
- Edited
DarkClaymore
ArthurHFSS
Both assessments are done: https://virtualbookshelf.home.blog/2019/02/06/webnovel-assessments-14/
Reviews are queued.
ANY REVIEW REQUESTS AFTER THIS WILL LIKELY NOT BE DONE FOR A LONG TIME
Sorry folks, gotta prioritize!
You can still ask for a review, but for the mean time, you'll only receive an assessment.
Instead of reviewing, I'll be working on a writing guide per suggestion.
Book_Keeper could you review mine as well please...
link : https://www.webnovel.com/book/12572987605958205/Purple-Dawn-Till-Dusk-%3A-dearest-trough-the-time
many thanks
Book_Keeper Thank you, Great Sage Book Keeper. This humble one shall await your wisdom with baited breath.
Could you please check my book... Thank you
https://m.webnovel.com/book/12564072806923405
Please do mine, I'd be extremely grateful if you do.
https://m.webnovel.com/book/12526421806756605
If anyone wanna swap, just @ me.
Book_Keeper Been on your site a lot so far. Message me if you wanna talk about website layout etc. . Hoping your review might uncover my issue of views but lack of collections. Perhaps you saw something while reviewing it for the assessment.
X_I_O i have added your novel into my library. will give you feedback once i have done... could you review mine as well please...
link : https://www.webnovel.com/book/12572987605958205/Purple-Dawn-Till-Dusk-%3A-dearest-trough-the-time
jikanyotomare Queued!
jikanyotomare
Review queued.
XiaoMeeHee X_I_O Ok!
Kyazi Oh, I'm glad to hear. :) Sure, website suggestions would be helpful! I can't do much in terms of design though since I'm limited by free hosting.
To be honest, I'm not very familiar with the views and collection statistics. From what I've read and reviewed so far, I haven't picked up on anything that would make one novel more popular than the other. It seems that after enough self-promotion, perhaps more people will discover the story and read it. However, one of the bases for this website is to encourage reading of more unknown novels by not judging from such statistics. Of course, this is yet to be perfected as the ideal situation would be to have synopses for each novel (or at least the 7+ ones). I'm still brainstorming ideas, so any suggestions on this would be great.
In short, there are plenty of good stories out there that receive little views. So take Webnovel's statistics with a grain a salt in using that to judge story quality. Conversely, I've seen some very mediocre novels (based on the VB score of 7 and less) have unusually high amounts of views and PS in comparison.