DragonKnov
1. History and Lore.
When we say magical academy, we aren't talking about the typical and original academies of, you know? Earth! Sometimes, academies here are either based on religious factors or political factors. (Sometimes, there are other reasons or history why it was built.)
When we talk about a magical academy, however, history and lore are something that I look for. Why was the academy built? Did a war between wizards and witches necessitate an academy (separately) for training future warriors? Was the school built for special children who couldn't control their powers? Such lore can intrigue a reader and can push them to read further.
- The System
Every academy has a system. There are what we call the valedictorians, salutatorians, etc. What does your academy have? Is there a rank system? Does it depend on a particular class? (Ex. Hufflepuff, Gryffindor, Slytherin, Ravenclaw)
If the system the authorities of the academy are well-thought, then you can expect your readers to be well-impressed.
- The Authorities.
An academy is nothing without thr authorities(leaders.) The characteristics of the principal(Is she the villain? Is she really good? Why does it seem like she's lying to her students?), the teachers (One is brave, the other is timid, the other is a future traitor of the academy)
Characteristics of such authorities interest me.
- The Anomaly
If the plot is nothing but the aim of the protagonist to climb the ranks, then you lost my interest. I love academies with a heavy lore that affects the future, which sometimes will lead the protagonists to certain threats. I love magic academies which has mystery-- the anomaly that drives suspense and thrill onward. For example, who blackmailed the pe teacher? Why is the academy being threatened by a writer whose pen name is the "Black Death"? Who is this Black Death?
Or... Let's say the protagonist finds some hidden switch that leads him to an unknown part of the academy. What will she find? What might be there? Will she ever come out?
- The students.
If your students are stereotyped, then you've lost my interest. For example, the one who stutters is usually timid, the one with glasses is the bookworm, the leonine dude is the bully, and the " one with different characters from the rest" is the protagonist. This is not always the case. If I were, I'd try to play with personalities a bit.
One thing that annoys me too is the perfect character. Add flaws. Not everyone is perfect.