WinterBud
It was, but I repay effort with effort.
As you are aware, I am not the best, but I will be honest.

I winter bud- well done your novel was on point. I must bow in admiration. But I still hate you... =]

      Forsaken1 LOL :joy: okay, I guess you were honest about that part. It's fine, I get it, I hated lazyredragon's guts too after reading his first chappie. I also wanted him (her? I don't care) to marry me, but that's beside the point. Thanks again :)

          Here is my novel Duality, I would really appreciate some feedback on it.

          Also, I've been told that the world building aspect was kinda lacking, so I've tried to improve it on the latest chapter. Please tell me what you think. Thanks.

            JohnnyKbca I only scanned the first couple of chaps. You seem to be an experienced writer with firsthand experience in the military. The first chaps reminded me of how Princess Agents began (a female lead novel here on WN, in case you didn't know). There was at least three chapters spent on the MC's original world with massive details about her last mission. I'll be honest, I only skimmed those chapters. The story promised me reincarnation/transmigration, and it was taking too long. She was going to leave that world anyway, I couldn't understand why all those details would really matter. Of course, after I skipped to the juicy part, the story became a lot more enjoyable. I'm just sharing this with you because your story seems to have that same problem. I saw a reviewer say it also became good after he transmigrated, right? Maybe try starting the story to when he revives and loop back to the past with less details? Hope this helps.

                WinterBud Thanks, I actually have no previous experience writing, save for a short story contest No use crying over spilled oil.

                I have never been in the military, but I did do some research on it, to make it seem more believable.

                And the prologue, before John dies, that was actually my story for the first writing prompts contest. I tried to do something different with it. Instead of focusing on what happens after reincarnating, the story would be entirely about the events leading up to the reincarnation. In the end however, I decided to keep on writing, and the prologue became kinda awkward because of that.

                    JohnnyKbca I see. Great job on your first effort. :)
                    I think it's a common mistake to try to smoothen awkward parts by piling on more details. The solution's usually the opposite, though. If you're going to rewrite in the future, try to isolate the truly indispensible details and let go of the rest.

                      WinterBud I was shocked when you reviewed my novel even though I didn't see you reply in this forum post. Well, I'll still swap with you. I'll do it either today or the next. I'll see if could go home early to read 🤣🤣

                          existing Thanks, I'm beginning to think I may have misunderstood the mechanics of review swaps. I thought it was free-for-all if you post in a thread like this, but maybe most people are just asking to swap with the OP? :joy: I was finding it a bit strange how everyone seems to be waiting for everyone else to give the first review haha, maybe that was why.

                              WinterBud It seems you also have to reply to their post and tell them you also want to swap :) And yes, I just realized most are waiting for the OP to reply or read their work first. You're one of the few who read my work immediately even before I replied to your comment.

                                My current reading list:

                                1. The Best Title by Alfwulf
                                2. Duality by JohnnyKbca
                                3. Love System: Changing Desitinies by dreamingjuliet

                                *If I missed anyone or I forgot a promised swap please let me know.

                                  Updated reading/swap list:

                                  1. Love System: Changing Desitinies by dreamingjuliet
                                  2. Nine-Tailed Fox by 0alex_reed0
                                    Write a Reply...
                                    Web Novel Novel Ask