Seshata

Sorry, I just wanted to ask if you got your PH.D, or just your masters? Obviously, I'm assuming you got your PH.D, but I can't a hundred percent be sure. I'm in a master's program for psychology and working on applying for doctorate programs.

Also, I feel your pain about grammar. I think it's one of those things that you have to try to understand, and you can't be taught. Often times, it seems people think they know grammar and try to give advice to others, meanwhile, they are commenting with absurd tense usage.

Also, I think authors should be able to take certain liberties in stores as many often do.

Anyways, just curious if you got your doctorate and where you got it.

    SrtaA First off, I enjoy your title! I like that the maiden is the mischievous one, and it's the prince who has to sleep his life away. I don't know if that's what your book is actually about, but I like this subversion of gendered tropes! :)

    First off, simple fix that again helps EVERYONE: in your first sentence, "Firm knocks ... made Alexa startle in anticipation" -- try to avoid "helping" verbs that dilute the power of your main action words. Startle is a great word, evokes a clear picture and emotional state. "made startle" doesn't really make sense, and your real action "startle" is lost in the rest of the sentence. "Firm knocks at the carriage door startled Alexa and Lady Cordelia." We don't know anything about them yet, so you don't need "the other maiden" here; it just muddles the opening line and slows it down. Also, I'm not positive you can "startle in anticipation." I would go with startle here, and then explain Cordelia turns toward the door in anticipation or something.

    Magnus von Wutenfall is SUCH a name omg. Love it.

    Alexa's personality is well-established in that first line of dialogue. And her curiosity shows through when she peers outside. Also, "A handsome face showed up." is a fabulous, funny one-liner para.

    In general, some of your sentences could be pared down a bit, just to help with the flow. For ex: "peered to the outside" should be "peered outside" ; also, "Alexa's violet eyes met the Prince's golden ones immediately. What she saw was the immediate shock in those eyes." should be "...(keep the first sent)... Shock widened his leonine gaze." (or whatever.) Moral of the story, we don't need two "immediate" anythings, and we don't need "what she saw was" because clearly she saw it, you just told us her eyes met his his, and that's what eyes do.

    Love the mercenary and the "honor is to be lost" line, plus the "bastard" line. Your short, pithy sentences are hilarious and great at characterization.

    "Concatenate" -- Bold choice. Doesn't quite flow with the story, might be a bit too intense a vocabulary term for the genre, since it's usually used in regards to coding. Also, I had to look that up to make sure I actually knew what it meant, and I have 4 degrees. Your average reader probably doesn't know that word off the top of their head. By all means, use advanced vocab and hold high expectations for your readers, but try to limit the really difficult words to times when no other word is as good.

    "Le mot juste" is a French phrase that essentially means "the perfect word." It's this idea that sometimes, authors find the absolute perfect word for a sentence or an idea, and when it comes together, it forms the most perfect sentiment. I don't think concatenate is "le mot juste" in that moment. Instead of perfectly flowing within the string of words around it, it stood out too much and hurt your flow.

    Okay, General Thoughts:
    Pros: Interesting historical period setting, great characterization of Alexa and Cordelia. Strong visual descriptions. Cordelia's description para was especially strong. Lovely vocabulary/diction. Some really funny lines. Great high-stakes ending for a first chapter. Solid build-up of the initial mystery--Who, or what, is Alexa? Why do people either hate or love her? Why does everyone think she may have assassinated a prince?

    Great opening in terms of story!

    Cons: Story-wise, the only light issue with the first chap is that the mysterious accident "two days ago" is more intriguing than the current predicament. I'd suggest including a few more details about what happened to her hands, how she saved people, who she was fighting, etc. You don't need too many or anything, but a few more details would help slake the hunger for backstory I was feeling.

    Grammar-wise, few small issues. As I've already mentioned, sentence structure is sometimes a little wordier than it needs to be, or rather, ordered a bit strangely to mess up the flow. Watch your prepositions like "out" "of" etc.
    For ex "watchful of the noble couple's clash of glances" is a bit awkward. Stick with "watching the noble couple's clash of glances"; "instinct of preservation" = "preservation instinct". Changes like this tighten up the language so the reader doesn't get bogged down so often.

    All in all, intriguing opening and all the makings of a fascinating tale! Keep up the great work with characterization, imagery, and diction; with a few tweaks to sentence construction, you'll be all the stronger a storyteller! :)

      SrtaA First off, I enjoy your title! I like that the maiden is the mischievous one, and it's the prince who has to sleep his life away. I don't know if that's what your book is actually about, but I like this subversion of gendered tropes! :)

      First off, simple fix that again helps EVERYONE: in your first sentence, "Firm knocks ... made Alexa startle in anticipation" -- try to avoid "helping" verbs that dilute the power of your main action words. Startle is a great word, evokes a clear picture and emotional state. "made startle" doesn't really make sense, and your real action "startle" is lost in the rest of the sentence. "Firm knocks at the carriage door startled Alexa and Lady Cordelia." We don't know anything about them yet, so you don't need "the other maiden" here; it just muddles the opening line and slows it down. Also, I'm not positive you can "startle in anticipation." I would go with startle here, and then explain Cordelia turns toward the door in anticipation or something.

      Magnus von Wutenfall is SUCH a name omg. Love it.

      Alexa's personality is well-established in that first line of dialogue. And her curiosity shows through when she peers outside. Also, "A handsome face showed up." is a fabulous, funny one-liner para.

      In general, some of your sentences could be pared down a bit, just to help with the flow. For ex: "peered to the outside" should be "peered outside" ; also, "Alexa's violet eyes met the Prince's golden ones immediately. What she saw was the immediate shock in those eyes." should be "...(keep the first sent)... Shock widened his leonine gaze." (or whatever.) Moral of the story, we don't need two "immediate" anythings, and we don't need "what she saw was" because clearly she saw it, you just told us her eyes met his his, and that's what eyes do.

      Love the mercenary and the "honor is to be lost" line, plus the "bastard" line. Your short, pithy sentences are hilarious and great at characterization.

      "Concatenate" -- Bold choice. Doesn't quite flow with the story, might be a bit too intense a vocabulary term for the genre, since it's usually used in regards to coding. Also, I had to look that up to make sure I actually knew what it meant, and I have 4 degrees. Your average reader probably doesn't know that word off the top of their head. By all means, use advanced vocab and hold high expectations for your readers, but try to limit the really difficult words to times when no other word is as good.

      "Le mot juste" is a French phrase that essentially means "the perfect word." It's this idea that sometimes, authors find the absolute perfect word for a sentence or an idea, and when it comes together, it forms the most perfect sentiment. I don't think concatenate is "le mot juste" in that moment. Instead of perfectly flowing within the string of words around it, it stood out too much and hurt your flow.

      Okay, General Thoughts:
      Pros: Interesting historical period setting, great characterization of Alexa and Cordelia. Strong visual descriptions. Cordelia's description para was especially strong. Lovely vocabulary/diction. Some really funny lines. Great high-stakes ending for a first chapter. Solid build-up of the initial mystery--Who, or what, is Alexa? Why do people either hate or love her? Why does everyone think she may have assassinated a prince?

      Great opening in terms of story!

      Cons: Story-wise, the only light issue with the first chap is that the mysterious accident "two days ago" is more intriguing than the current predicament. I'd suggest including a few more details about what happened to her hands, how she saved people, who she was fighting, etc. You don't need too many or anything, but a few more details would help slake the hunger for backstory I was feeling.

      Grammar-wise, few small issues. As I've already mentioned, sentence structure is sometimes a little wordier than it needs to be, or rather, ordered a bit strangely to mess up the flow. Watch your prepositions like "out" "of" etc.
      For ex "watchful of the noble couple's clash of glances" is a bit awkward. Stick with "watching the noble couple's clash of glances"; "instinct of preservation" = "preservation instinct". Changes like this tighten up the language so the reader doesn't get bogged down so often.

      All in all, intriguing opening and all the makings of a fascinating tale! Keep up the great work with characterization, imagery, and diction; with a few tweaks to sentence construction, you'll be all the stronger a storyteller! :)

        Lilliny I'm a semicolon abuser myself, so I feel your struggle. :) Good luck with your story!!

          Another good review from Sensei. I be taking notes. :smile_cat:

          kazesenken I am stoked to finish it. I'll give you my thoughts via Review when I'm all done. And you're right; you do a great job conveying meaning. The "pretty" will come with practice! :)

            ihateyounot Bahahaha, careful what you ask for. ;)
            And thanks! I love seeing writers come into their own, and there are so many GOOD IDEAS floating around this site, I thought it would be awesome if everyone could get their stories out in the universe in a way that everyone could enjoy! I hate visual art because nothing I draw ever looks like what I'm imagining in my head. Drives me nuts. I had a feeling several authors feel that way about their stories. They have these amazing ideas, but when they try to write them down, the story doesn't flow as beautifully as it does in their minds. I'd like to help make those lofty dreams a reality. :)

              Piokilek Love 'em! Honestly, I'm as genre-fluid a reader as they come. I read it all! As long as the story's compelling, I'll read anything. Might be a few days before I get to your novel, but I will eventually get to it for sure!

                Her_Shadow
                Hello! Good luck with PhD applications; that's such a nightmare experience! One of my best friends spent months applying to Clinical Psych PhDs last year, so I'm all too familiar. I'll be sending you positive good-luck vibes!

                And good question. I actually have an MA in English with a specialized license for English Education, and I have an MFA in Creative Writing, which is a terminal degree, so I can teach at the university level. I'll be heading back to school for a PhD fall 2021, though, which will allow me to expand my curriculum to include folklore and anthropology studies. I also have two BAs, because why not? Haha, essentially, I'm a school junkie, tbh.

                Graduated from Spalding University's School of Creative and Professional Writing (highly recommend for anyone interested in an MFA! One of the best experiences of my creative career/life!) and from Harvard University.

                Re: your grammar comment: AHH SO TRUE. I feel it's really easy for well-read people to know when something's wrong or off, but it's an entirely different skill set to be able to accurately explain WHAT is wrong. It requires a specialized vocabulary that's sometimes difficult to come by. It also seems like many people are savvy enough to tell when grammatical construction is off in someone else's writing, but they can't see the same faux pas in their own.

                And YES YES YES! I absolutely believe all art rules were made to be broken. My fave quote regarding this is: "Learn the rules like a pro, so you can break them like an artist" -attributed to Pablo Picasso. What I love about WebNovel and other platforms like Archive of Our Own is that it grants the freedom to artists to take liberties and press boundaries and experiment freely! What those artists need to do this successfully, however, is that initial grounding in the fundamentals. You can't break a rule like an artist until you know it's a rule to begin with!

                Super excited to read your story, btw! A Psych master writing about sadism--HELLS YES SIGN ME UP. :)

                  Seshata
                  Oh yeah, definitely. I'm a visual artist myself (I drew my profile picture) and it's actually worse than writing, honestly. Drives me insane XD

                    Seshata OMG I always wanted to take creative writing!!
                    Begged my mum to let me take creative writing as my university major but she absolutely forbade it... since it was useless. Uurgh... I loved to read and write and wanted to learn more about making my own writing better but NOPE.
                    She's an intellectual and has a PHD in something like Statistics, Economy, ICT, Business Management etc, and didn't look too kindly on me wasting time on learning something that won't be stable in the long run. Huhu.

                    Well look who's laughing now! Muahahahahaha! I'm writing novels and there are even Lit Professors here. XD
                    Though I still am getting basically no income out of it. lol. I graduated university 2 years ago NOT in creative writing btw. So it was an old gripe of mine.

                    Now that I've gotten that out of the way, thank you for giving us your time!

                    I have written two interconnecting novels. The first I wrote a while ago so mind you, the first chapter definitely isn't the best...
                    The second novel's first chappy is probably is average too, to be honest. haha.

                    Writing the introductions is a bit difficult I guess because of how you need to hook the readers and give them enough information at the same time. It gets A LOT better afterwards. At least I think it does... ( •᷄⌓•᷅ )
                    Well, I've never had a teacher to help me through it, like almost everyone else on the platform.

                    I was hoping you would not only criticize, but also tell me if you could feel the connection between the two. Or if the foreshadowing is enough.
                    The first novel is the original, while the second is the prologue to the original.

                    Original (20 chapters):
                    https://www.webnovel.com/book/14326033605988405/Undercover-Superstar-%3A-A-Song-of-Pyros-and-Snowflakes

                    The prologue is also entered into the WPC (writing prompts contest) #101
                    Prologue (5 chapters):
                    https://www.webnovel.com/book/16188206206239705/Undercover-Superstar%3A-The-Birth-of-Xiaolang

                    Please and thank you! You don't know how much this actually means to me TT

                      Chryiss Just out of curiosity, are you not gonna drop your own novel for some feedback?
                      You give amazing reviews yet ask for none in return. i'm assuming because you don't want any buttered reviews clogging your story.
                      So I'm wondering why in this post you don't mind not asking for some lit professor feedback

                        Azzack Well this lit professor would definitely be a good choice lol!

                        I did do some review swaps a while back when I first joined this site, but I did notice very quickly that the majority of people didn't give very good reviews in return, so I haven't asked since. I'm only curious about serious feedback for one of my stories. But that story is no longer updated on this website, only on Royal Road. I've gotten some great reviews on that site which have helped me tremendously. Once I finish writing the first book of that series, I plan to revise and rewrite it entirely. Thus, in short, I have no need for reviews for the time being. (:

                        And thank you! Glad that my reviews are deemed as such. :3

                        Azzack

                        Now that's ironically hilarious. For the prejudiced academic clique, anything economy/business counts against the concept of intellectual.

                        Observe that I'm referring to the in-club prejudice and nothing factual at all.

                        Seshata

                        Hello, it is great what you are doing here. I am not an english native speaker and i know that my skills are limited (especially vocabulary and word usages), but i would be more than happy to have an opinion from an english lit teacher.

                        If you can, i would appreciate if you could read for example the first chapter and then one of the last ones to see if an improvement can be felt.

                        https://dynamic.webnovel.com/book/15465781005526105?utm_source=writerShare&utm_campaign=241142573

                        EDIT: Just added you to my library for reference. I think i took some wrong habit learning passively from all these badly translated works. Already a word i didn't know just on the second page of chapter 1 😅. Very interesting first chapter by the way.

                          Seshata Your reviews sure verify you as a scholar.
                          I really really enjoyed all your feedbacks leaving aside the fact that I haven't read a single story which you have reviewed on this thread. They were quite intriguing and fun to read. Your words hauled some stories towards my library. Good luck and keep up this amazing work!

                          I think, my ships gonna sail more towards reviewers than writers in the upcoming days 😆

                          Seshata Thank you very much for the analysis and advices!
                          I still haven't this scale to weigh vocabulary. Concatenate is a common expression to me, but not to my reader. It really depends the people you talk everyday, the books you read in your life, and how your vocabulary was built during your lifetime. Sometimes those words are the perfect choice to me, but it seems not everyone agree! Also, I come from a culture where we avoid saying things directly, so I tend to soften everything. It's a vice I shouldn't be transfering to English, I know.

                          About the story con you cited, well, I decided to start in medias res, so in the next chapters what happened before is fully detailed. Does it count?
                          Writing in English is a new thing to me. We usually can see what is odd in other's work, and become blind to our own flaws. But you are absolutely right about the flaws in my work, and your advices are gold.

                            Seshata

                            Thanks for the good wishes!

                            I'm currently studying at New York University for my Masters, and hoping to get into any Clinical Ph.D program because the acceptance rates to clinical programs are so low! I think they accept like 10 people per program, and it's a fully paid for ride, however, for that reason it's so hard to get accepted to a program ( I think the acceptance rate is under 5% for some programs)!

                            As for my story, just a fair warning, it's mostly fun and games and doesn't reflect the mind of a discerning psychologist, and more so is just for the sake of fun and definitely not literary excellence.

                            I tend to let certain rules go to the wayside, and occasionally misuse an oxford comma here or there. My sentence structure is based on nothing more then ensuring that the reading experienced is maximized, and I literally know nothing about literary form.

                            I use alliteration once in a blue moon, and I'm rather quixotic in spell checking my errors. Regardless, appreciate any feed back and thanks for taking the time to read even a piece of it!

                            Also, don't expect a sprawling vocabulary full of innuendos and laden with riveting prose about the characters plight. I sort of tend to hack away at any words that seem to clunky and definitely am afraid of making my work hard to read. Not that you don't need to study a million words to get into a Ph.D program, but yeah, thanks for giving it a shot!

                              Seshata
                              I like the fact that you started your story with a retelling of past glories. You can tell the MC is hung up on his past. You can also tell that shit will hit the fan before you even reach the end of the chapter and read it for yourself.
                              The MC's voice is also sarcastic and hilarious. The references to video games makes it even more relatable to the readers.
                              I might have found some paragraphs a bit infodumpy for my taste tbh. When you speak of his sister sending him emojis on where he should shove his trophy, then dusting it off, sending pics to annoy the parents. It's nice to know that their parents don't approve, but it may be too early to delve into that. I spaced out a little during those paragraphs and had to re-read them.
                              Other than that, it's a solid start, makes me want to read more.

                                Web Novel Novel Ask