Hi, guys. I literally started just a couple of hours ago with my first 2 chapters and I feel like I'm doing something wrong. It's only 2 chapters as I've sent this but I would like an honest review of the writing I've done so far since not much of the story has been fleshed out yet and I'm still trying to introduce the characters. Thank you!

Title: Transmigrated Mind
Genre: Fantasy (Magic and whatnot)

https://www.webnovel.com/book/transmigrated-mind_20465943505550705###

Synopsis:
Here I am again, stuck in the darkness of my own room. Surrounded by thoughts that has been plaguing my mind since the day I've decided to drop out of college. Yes, that's me. John Colton. A 28 year old college dropout now leeching off his parents, refusing to make a living on his own. But no, this isn't a story about how useless of a son I am. No... This is the story of the time where I got lost in my mind and got transported to another world. A world where magic and mythical beings exist.

    Praefactuss
    Well first of all why is your synopsis the same as your first paragraph? They should not be the same. Second of all, your paragraph is far far too big and chunky. You should make new paragraphs every time someone new is talking for instance. As it is now, your whole story looks extremely confusing and hard to read. Also, don't use * to symbolise thought. It looks extremely weird. You can try using ' for thought and " for speech if necessary. B

      Temis Will do! Thank you!

      I already edited the chapters and hopefully it's easier to read

        @SEP1A I've read up to chapter 9. Here are my thoughts:

        1. Footnotes

        Don't completely rely on footnotes to give exposition. Always assume that readers skip over it.

        For something as important as Veren, you should give some information about why Noe named it that and what it is within the chapter itself. If you leave the definition at the bottom, the reader will be confused until they reach the end of the chapter.

        Same thing with Gremlin, but you really only need a small sentence to describe that.

        For stuff like autism and nehruma, it's fine because most people already know what autism is, and not knowing the meaning of nehruma doesn't really affect the story.

        2. Roundabout Wording

        For the most part, your prose is quite good, but there are some points where you tend to describe things in too much of a roundabout way.

        For example, in chapter five, when you described the showers, I initially thought Noe and Eris were in a cave, and there was a waterfall. Try to be a little more literal, so the setting won't be too confusing to visualize.

        3. Scene Breaks

        There are a few places where the scene completely changes, having a different time and location.

        Most notably, in the second chapter, "Warmth," you wrote, "'We'll be fine on our own,' she clutches Noe's burning hand."

        After that, the scene shifts into Allery bullying Noe. Keep in mind that if you put extra spaces between paragraphs, webnovel will automatically delete those in the published chapter. Try using asterisks or dashes to indicate scene breaks and avoid confusion.

        4. Abdormal

        At first, I thought it a misspelling, but then I read the paragraph comments.

        Make sure that you actually say in the story that there's a reason why Allery says that. For example, one of his buddies could point out the error, but Allery snaps at the other guy, saying that "abdormal" is the correct spelling or something like that.

        You can't just write a spelling error and expect readers to infer that it reflects the speaker's character.

        5. Blank Faces

        I'm having a hard time differentiating Lancaster and Terry in my head. I can visualize Bodhi, Eris, and the other characters because they have defining features, but Lancaster and Terry blend into the same person in my mind.

        Try to give them some defining characteristics that you mention every now and then, just like Bodhi's glasses.

        6. Synopsis

        It needs some work. Try to explain some of the magical aspects of your story and the main conflict.

        Refer to https://blog.reedsy.com/write-blurb-novel/

        7. Initial Tone

        The prelude sets the tone for a post-apocalyptic sci-fi story with a hint of thriller and military. But then, the story shifts into a fantasy school with magic, ghosts, and monsters.

        An easy fix would be to mention the fantastical elements in your prelude, or you could cut it altogether since it wouldn't affect the story that much if you sprinkle in some exposition about the world.

        That's about it. Hope I could help.

          Epyonnn Thank you so much for your in-depth review. You've given me extremely helpful points; I cherish them. I'll see what I can do about each and every one of the improvements you brought up. Once again, thank you for your time and effort!

            SEP1A this is a little thing I forgot to mention, but past tense is the standard for almost all novels these days. Though, I wouldn’t blame you if you don’t want to go through your entire novel to change every single verb.

              Epyonnn I also considered tense when coming up with my story. By not making my story first person point of view, I believed making it present tense would restore a semblance of the intimacy I sacrificed. In your opinion, do you think this still holds true or would sticking to industry standard be more important? I only care about producing the best narrative possible for Noe’s life.

                SEP1A I don't think there's anything wrong with what you're doing, but it's just harder to write in the present tense, and some readers don't like it. Do what you think is best for the story, since the tense is up to the author to decide.

                As for the intimacy part, I don't really feel any different than if it had been written in the first person or in the past tense. I don't know if that's just a me thing.

                Since I don't have much knowledge on the effects of tense, try looking up the pros and the cons to see what suits your story best.

                  Finally, a thread like this!! I was wondering because I go and get a review swap from others and saw that some just copy and paste their review and give 4-5 stars on the book itself just to gain the count for the book (LOL) and it's kinda frustrating to see because I honestly try to read a few chapters into the book and see what can be done to improve it even if I'm not much of a reader.

                  Anyways, I hope someone will be interested to pick this one up :D


                  Title: Luna's Diaries

                  Book 1: Secrets, Lies, and Deception

                  Genre: Romance, Slice of Life
                  Tags: Female Lead, Riches to Rags, High School Drama, Coming of Age
                  Schedule: Every Sunday and Wednesday 18:00 (GMT +8:00)

                  Link: https://www.webnovel.com/book/luna's-diaries_18722276206893505

                  Synopsis:
                  Luna Harper, a senior high school student of Greenfield University, is also known to be the reigning Queen since freshman year. She's known to be the Queen of Bad Behavior but the Sweet and Proper Daughter of the Harper Industries. She truly has it all - the fame, the status, and beauty.

                  She went missing for a year and returned to the University with a secret and is as if everything is still perfect. Her life isn't the same as before anymore because of one mistake that ruined her life. She has become a fragile girl that is walking with a ticking bomb.

                  Her everything suddenly became nothing until she meets Nathaniel Cooper.

                  alernatetext

                    Hey! I am comparatively new author and would be glad to get somd pointers and advice from fellow authors. Would appreciate any opinion.
                    Thank you in advance!

                    SPACE LORD
                    Genre: Fantasy, Action, adventure
                    Tags: Reincarnation, Magic, progression, cultivation, war and military, nobles
                    Synopsis:
                    Killed by a Restoration Emperor and reborn as his 12-year-old self, Theo was given a second chance at life. A second chance to save his family and survive in the coming hardships. He will once again battle against Emperor and his armies on the battlefields. With the vast knowledge of magic and battle energy he accumulated in his previous life, wielding the most unique treasure, he shall reach the pinnacle of magic once again.

                    What to expect from the story:

                    -Intelligent, experienced, and careful MC

                    -Detailed worldbuilding, serving to introduce the reader to the fantasy world

                    -Some elements from the eastern cultivation genre

                    -A steadfast focus on MC's story and his actions in his attempts to change the future

                    Link:
                    https://m.webnovel.com/book/space-lord_17433895806977305#

                      @theanneleen I've read up to chapter three. It's not bad, but it's not my type of genre, so I didn't feel like reading any further. Anyway, here are my thoughts.

                      1. All Hail the Queen

                      What exactly is the Queen in your story? Is it the person with the most influence in the school. If so, what can they do with that influence. What makes a queen? How did Luna become the Queen in the first place?

                      The schools where I come from don't have Queens. In fact, nobody really rules the school at all (other than the principal and staff, of course). There are some "cool kids," but it's not like they have any influence on the student body.

                      You need to make sure that you explain the significance of the term Queen. You can't just throw the word around and expect people to infer everything. Consider creating a scene or two about how Luna can use her power, and maybe a short flashback of when she used to go to the school.

                      In addition to this, you also need to develop the social hierarchy in the school some more. So far, we've only seen the high-classed individuals, and they really haven't done much. Is there even any reason to be a high-classed student?

                      So far, Luna doesn't really have any motivations for becoming the Queen again, other than she used to be one. What's so good about being the Queen, other than you have social power?

                      You've done a good job at introducing conflict with the Transferee, but Luna needs to have her own motivations in mind. So far, she's mostly reacting to the circumstances around her, trying to cover up her past and trying to deal with the Transferee.

                      2. Proofread

                      There are many little mistakes that you could easily catch if you proofread some more (I usually end up reading through my chapters three times). Two should be fine if you're short on time.

                      Also, some sentences are worded confusingly. Try reading some sentences out loud to see if they flow well.

                      Finally, you tend to switch between present and past tense during narration. I think that your main tense is past, but it changes every now and then. If you plan on fully writing the story in the past tense, there isn't much of a reason to suddenly change to the present tense.

                      That's about it. I didn't see anything wrong with the plot so far other than the whole Queen thing. I hope I could help.

                        Epyonnn
                        Sorry mate, I've been leaving you to do this alone. Kinda busy right now. I'll try to make some time to come by more often.

                          Epyonnn

                          Hi there! Thank you so much for taking up to review my novel. I really didn't think of that one actually. It was only then on my draft chapter 24 that I started out actually building the social hierarchy and background of the friendship between the girls and what it means that Luna is Queen because she was caught up with the Transferee.

                          Thank you really. I will keep this in mind :D It really helps!

                          Hello! I've just started my story and would really appreciate an honest critique. Thanks!

                          Title: Chaos Awakening
                          Genre: Fantasy, Male lead
                          Synopsis:
                          All his life, Cilix Trimaran felt as if something's been missing, a hole in his being that cannot be filled even if he tried to. He chalked it up to his broken memory. There were pieces, bits of the past that he can't seem to remember however hard he tried. Memories close enough to reach, but vague enough that it kept slipping past his fingers like smoke. And then there was Oleah.
                          Oleah Vanderbilt was a model student. She was powerful, excelled in whatever task she put herself into, a woman of many talents. But her cold disposition and blank stares grate something in Cilix that he can't put his finger onto. There was something in those eyes that seems to call out to him.
                          He just have to find out, doesn't he? Good thing his group of misfits accidentally uncovered a conspiracy in the ministry and seem to want to initiate an anarchy. Good riddance, in Cilix's humble opinion.

                          Link: https://www.webnovel.com/book/chaos-awakening_20316599005138205

                            alernatetext

                            LINK: THE KEEPER OF UNHOLY MIGHT

                            TAG: ACTION, FANTASY, ADVENTURE, ACTION, MAGIC, MALEPROTAGONIST, MONSTER, CULTIVATION, EVILMC

                            SYNOPSIS:
                            Nicolaus Asenon had a detached feeling and drifted through life aimlessly.
                            Everything he had done had no purpose. He had sacrificed almost everything in his life for the sake of his work.
                            Family, friends, and mindset were all taken away one by one. His mentality, bit by bit becoming corrupted.
                            In his darkest hours. He was struck by a vehicle and died. As a result; his eyesight started to dim and he gave his final breath.
                            In a world without mercy. He had transmigrated from the modern world to an alternative universe.
                            With no remorse, Nicolaus Asenon is willing to go to any lengths to reap benefits. As a corrupted man. He already has no qualms.
                            He has now seen all that life has to offer, transforming him into a cold, merciless, cunning villain, never allowing himself to get attached to anybody who may get in the way of his ultimate goal.
                            This is the story of a man cultivating his strength to rise up above all... A Lord overlooking the entire world!

                            ...................................
                            I would like for any opinions please, to see if my novel is subpar or great compared the other novels in this platform.

                              Web Novel Novel Ask