• Diss

  • Your novel is trash if it has harem

Yeah you are using same logic as all guys are dogs and all girls are bitches. Some might be but not all i have read many trash novel with harem but does that mean all harem are wrong the answer is always gonna be no.
(Fun fact : the whole mahabharat (hindu mythology) happened because a woman married 5 brothers it was polygamy in a way.)

    Misguided_Rooster There is no way anyone would ever believe capitalism is good. After all, what about the poor people?

    There is no way anyone would ever believe socialism is good. After all, who would work without incentives?

    What you stated is just your belief. And that alone is okay. But what you did, is insult a lot of people and a lot of their hard work (and a lot of the laidback, trash-tier works as well). That's not okay.

    In other words, you are the one in the wrong. Not because of the belief itself, but because you somehow reached a conclusion that your beliefs are superior to others.

    If I recall, the last group that used this line of thinking was wiped out in '45

        Shubhangi_Kene Don't even bring up Mahabharat! I'm still salty about how they treated my boi Karna.
        Dude was literally the son of the Sun god, yet he got the short end of the stick at every single turn. And his fricken brother killed him by shooting him in the back.

        I was this close to writing a fan fic where the dude got regressed in time and then goes around murdering everyone who wronged him.

            Misguided_Rooster From a historical perspective, monogamy is trash.

            From a literature perspective, it CAN be a useful plot tool. This is particularly so as polygamy was the default for most of human history. Love, admittedly, had little to do with it though as it was primarily for procreation and ensuring the continuation of lineage.

            Unfortanately, most authors do not seem to know how to use it. I've read very few harem works where the handling of the harem did not detract from the plot of the story and fewer still where it added value to it. This is the fault of the writers though, not the harem tag.

              What about court romance novels? That’s got harem in it. Is that allowed?

                MotivatedSloth
                I'm fine with insulting them. I don't think it's superior, don't overreach. All I stated was that if you have a harem in your novel, of course relating to the MC, your novel is trash. I've been reading for 4-5 years now and did indeed come to this conclusion.

                Harem is fanservice. It's there to please those who like it. What does it add to a story? Nothing but stupidity and filler. Let's not even talk about a normal thinking human suddenly marrying 5 different girls because he loves them all, nor mention the sexism(or in some cases extreme levels of stupidity) in chinese novels(which has a lot to do with this).

                Just ask yourself, can this novel do without a harem. Majority of novels have some sort of harem when there is literally no need and it makes no freaking sense to have. Please don't use the 'political marriage' bullshit.

                I don't care if I offend people. I will straight up tell you if your novel is trash if it is.

                Harem is trash and will always be trash. Every single auhor that has a harem in their stories is a cheap and lame author. I hope you get arthitis.

                    Harem can be good in a story, especially in RI. Imagine if Fang Yuan started killing all of Giant Sun Immortal Venerables harem members (100,000+ women), wouldn't that be satisfying?

                    Web Novel Novel Ask